0
Flyer for the Risk Digital UK/EU global livestream featuring an image of Lily Li, Founder/President of Metaverse Law Corporation.

Metaverse Law Presents at #RISK DIGITAL UK/EU

Metaverse Law’s Lily Li recently spoke at the #Risk Digital UK/EU global livestream last week
for two sessions: “A New Era of AI Governance” and “The Role of
Technology in Modern Governance, Risk and Compliance.”

Lily’s presentations included an overview about artificial
intelligence risks and discussed the latest developments in European
Union and United States AI legislation and regulations. Major
developments in the US include:
— NY and Illinois AI bias legislation in employment
— Colorado comprehensive AI legislation
— California AI bills that have recently passed the legislature.

Lily also touched on how the results of the U.S. presidential election
could impact the AI landscape, either through changes in FTC priority
and state legislation, and the need for AI risk management and
governance programs.

The law in this area is developing very quickly and will affect
businesses in almost every industry. Keeping up with these changes is
critical as businesses deploy and integrate AI into everyday operations.

You can learn more about #Risk Digital and watch on-demand content by clicking on the link: https://www.grcworldforums.com/risk/risk-digital

#Risk Digital is one of a number of conferences organized by GRC World
Forums, a producer of in-person and livestream educational events for
governance, risk and compliance professionals.

0
Photo of American flag and California flag on a flagpole with a palm tree in the background.

California Wraps Its 2024 Legislative Session with Data Privacy & AI Bills

California’s legislative session closed on August 31, 2024 with a series of data privacy and AI bills. Over the course of September, Governor Newsom signed 17 bills covering AI technologies. This wave of legislation comes a year after Governor Newsom signed an Executive Order to help ensure California is ready for next wave of AI technologies.   Below is an overview of new and noteworthy AI and data privacy bills, beginning with six amendments to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) followed by a range of signed and vetoed AI-related bills.   Passed CCPA Amendments  
  1. SB 1223and AB 1008: Neural Data, Personal Information and AI Systems
What Does the CCPA Require? Currently, the CCPA requires a business collects that collection personal information about a consumer to limit its use of the consumer’s sensitive personal information. “Sensitive personal information” includes biometric information for the purposes of identifying a consumer, but not neural data. Additionally, the CCPA does not specify if personal information can exist in various formats.   What Changes? Under SB 1223, the CCPA’s definition of “sensitive personal information” would be expanded. It would include consumer’s neural data, or “information that is generated by measuring the activity of the consumer’s central or peripheral nervous system, and that is not inferred from nonneural information.”   Under AB 1008, the CCPA would also specify that “personal information can exist in various formats,” including physical, digital or abstract information, which may be in the form of encrypted files, metadata, or AI systems capable of outputting personal information.   Governor Newsom signed SB 1223 and AB 1008 into law on September 28, 2024. Both laws will become applicable on January 1, 2025.  
  1. AB 1824: Opt-Out Right, Mergers
What Does the CCPA Require? The CCPA states that consumers shall have the right to opt out of a business selling or sharing their personal information. However, the Act does not specify the requirements for honoring those requests upon a merger or acquisition.   What Changes? Under this bill, if a business transfers personal information to another business as part of a merger, acquisition, bankruptcy or other transaction, they must comply with the original opt-out requests of the transferring business.   Governor Newsom signed AB 1824 into law on September 29, 2024. This law takes effect on January 1, 2025.  
  1. AB 3286: Monetary Thresholds, Grants
What Does the CCPA Require? The CCPA grants the Attorney General rights to adjusting monetary thresholds to reflect an increase in the Consumer Price Index.   What Changes? This bill removes the responsibility of adjusting monetary thresholds from the Attorney General and places it on the California Privacy Protection Agency, among other minor changes.   Governor Newsom signed AB 3286 on July 15, 2024, and the law goes into effect on January 1, 2025.     Vetoed CCPA Amendments  
  1. AB 1949: Collection of Personal Information of a Consumer Less than 18 Years of Age
What Does the CCPA Require? The CCPA provides a consumer with specific rights regarding their personal information. Currently, the CCPA prohibits a business from selling or sharing personal information of a consumer if the business has actual knowledge that the consumer is less than 16 years old, unless they or their parent or guardian have properly consented.   What Changes? This bill would raise that age from 16 to 18 years old, meaning that a business shall not sell or share the personal information of one who is between 13 and 18 years old unless the consumer or their parent or guardian consents. A business shall not share or sell information of a child younger than 13 years old unless their parent or guardian consent.   Additionally, this bill would require a business to treat a consumer as younger than 18 years old if the consumer transmits a signal indicating they are younger than 18. The bill retains the CCPA’s “actual knowledge or willful disregard” standard for violations.   Finally, the bill requires California’s Attorney General to adopt regulations that include technical specifications for an opt-out preference signal that allows the consumer to specify if they are less than 13 years old, or between 13 and 18 years old.   Governor Newsom vetoed AB 1949 on September 28, 2024.  
  1. AB 3048: Opt-Out Preference Signals
What Does the CCPA Require? The CCPA states that consumers shall have the right to opt out of a business selling or sharing their personal information. To send opt-out preference signals now, users have to download plugins for major browsers which may vary by browser type.   Currently, the only opt-out preference signal recognized by the CCPA per Attorney General Rob Bonta’s FAQ page and supporting resources by the California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA)  is the Global Privacy Control (GPC). However under the CCPA, the GPC is intended only to communicate with Do Not Sell requests for a global privacy control. Still, this is an enforced area of privacy law: In 2022, a Final Judgment and Permanent Injunction against Sephora ordered the company to pay $1.2 million to resolve claims that Sephora did not process opt-out requests set through privacy controls.    What Changes? This bill is targeted at businesses who develop or maintain browsers, mandating that they must include settings that enable consumers to send an opt-out preference signal to businesses they interact with on the browser. After rulemaking and agency adoptions, the bill would also prohibit a business from developing or maintaining a mobile operating system that does not include opt-out preference signal settings. These provisions would go into effect beginning January 1, 2026.   Governor Newsom vetoed AB 3048 on September 20, 2024.   Passed AI Bills  
  1. SB 2013: Generative Artificial Intelligence, Training Data Transparency
Who Does This Apply to? This bill applies to “generative artificial intelligence” systems or services, which is defined as AI that can “generate derived synthetic content…that emulates the structure and characteristics of the [AI’s] training data.” There is no consumer use or monetary threshold, such that this definition seems to be far-reaching.   What Changes? This bill requires that the developers of all covered generative AI systems available to Californians must post information on their website. This information must include the data used to train the AI system or service, and a high-level summary of the datasets used in the system.   Bill SB 2013 was signed by Governor Newsom on September 28, 2024. This law will go into effect on January 1, 2026.  
  1. AB 2885: Artificial Intelligence, Definition
Who Does This Apply to? According to the preamble of the bill, the definition applies to actions taken by the Department of Technology, local agencies, the California Online Community College, and social media companies, under requirements of existing laws.   What Changes? The term “artificial intelligence” for these purposes would be altered to include an “engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy” and can generate output based on inferences made from its input.   Bill AB 2885 was signed by Governor Newsom on September 28, 2024. Provisions of this law will go into effect on January 1, 2025.  
  1. SB 942: California AI Transparency Act
Who Does This Apply to? This bill applies to “covered providers,” which includes persons that create, code or otherwise produce generative AI systems with over 1 million monthly visitors and are within California state.   What Changes? Under this bill, covered providers would be required to make publicly accessible AI detection tools. They would also be required to provide the user an option to include a disclosure, as well as provide a latent disclosure in content created or altered by the generative AI system.   Governor Newsom signed SB 942 into law on September 19, 2024, along with other bills addressing concerns around AI:  
  • SB 926prohibits creating and distributing sexually explicit realistic images of a person when those images are intended to cause serious emotional distress of the person. This bill is targeted at AI-generated sexually explicit content. Similarly, AB 1831 expands the existing child pornography statutes to include content created or altered by generative AI.
 
  • SB 981requires social media platforms to provide Californians with a mechanism to report digital identity theft on platform. Following the aim of Bill 926, this would include reporting AI images of a certain person whose identity has been stolen appearing to be engaged in certain sexual acts.
 
  1. AB 3030: Health Care Services, Artificial Intelligence
Who Does This Apply to? This bill applies to health facilities, clinics, physician’s offices, or other health group practices that use generative AI for communications about patient clinical information. “Patient clinical information” is defined as information relating to the health status of a patient, and specifically excludes administrative matters, such as appointment scheduling, billing, or “other clerical or business matters.”   What Changes? Under this bill, generative AI which pertains to clinical information must include: 1) a disclaimer that indicates the communication was generated by AI at the beginning of the interaction, and 2) clear instructions on how that patient can contact the appropriate person.   Governor Newsom signed AB 3030 into law on September 28, 2024. The law goes into effect immediately.   Similarly, SB 1120 was passed on September 28, 2024 and provides specific restrictions for health care service places or disability insurers who use AI in their decisionmaking. Under this law, health service plans must have specific policies and procedures in place, and must be overseen by a medical director with an unrestricted license to practice medicine in the state of California.  
  1. AB 1836: Use of Likeness, Digital Replica
Who Does This Apply to? This bill is intended to protect intellectual property, and applies to those creating digital replicas of another’s likeness. A “digital replica” means a “computer-generated, highly realistic electronic representation” that one can readily identify as a likeness of the person being replicated.   What Changes? This bill makes a person who makes or distributes a digital replica of a deceased personality’s voice or likeness, without that person’s consent, liable for the greater of $10,000 or the amount actually suffered.   Governor Newsom signed AB 1836 into law on September 17, 2024. The law goes into effect immediately.   Similarly, Governor Newsom also signed AB 2602 into law on the same date. This law prohibits personal or professional service contracts that contain provisions for the use of a digital replica or likeness for a general purpose, unless the individual is represented by legal counsel. Instead, the contract must contain a reasonably specific description of the intended uses of the digital replica.  
  1. SB 2355: Political Advertisements, Artificial Intelligence
Who Does This Apply to? This bill applies to committees who create, publish or otherwise distribute political advertisements. These advertisements include all political ads that contain any image, audio, or video that is “generated or substantially altered” using AI.   What Changes? Under this bill, there are specific requirements for each format of ad. For example, a video advertisement shall include disclosures at the beginning or end of the advertisement and must be displayed for five or ten seconds, depending on the length of the ad.   Governor Newsom signed AB 2355 into law on September 17, 2024. The law goes into effect immediately.   Similarly, Governor Newsom also signed AB 2655 and AB 2839 into law on September 17, 2024.   AB 2655, known as the Defending Democracy from Deepfake Deception Act of 2024, requires large online platforms (those with at least 1 million California users) to: 1) remove deceptive and digitally modified election content from their platforms, or 2) to label that content before and after the election if the content has been reported to the platform.   AB 2839 prohibits the knowing distribution of advertisements or other election communication that contains materially deceptive content within 120 days of an election in California, and in some cases, 60 days after an election.   Vetoed AI Bills
  1. SB 1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act
Who Does This Apply to? This bill is directed toward high-complexity AI models, such as those whose floating operations exceed $100,000,000. Other than requirements in state data privacy laws and the Colorado AI Act, there are no AI laws of this scale enacted in the U.S.   What Changes? For these covered models, the bill has various requirements, including a written safety and security protocol, submission of that protocol to the Attorney General, and implementing the ability to promptly enact a shutdown.   Under this bill, the Attorney General may bring a civil action for a violation that causes death or harm to people or property, or that constitutes an imminent risk to public safety. Notably, this penalty is calculated by computing power. For the first violation, the penalty will be no more than 10% of the cost of the quantity of computing power used to train the covered model, and subsequent violations may not exceed 30% of that value.   Governor Newsom vetoed SB 1047 on September 29, 2024. In his decision, Governor Newsom considered that “California is home to 32 or the world’s 50 leading AI companies.” He noted that the bill applies only to these extensive and large-scale models, while “[s]maller, specialized models may emerge as equally or even more dangerous than the models targeted by SB- 1047 – at the potential expense of curtailing the very innovation that fuels advancement in the favor of public good” by these large-scale models.
0
Chicago Grand Central Looking Up

2024 U.S. regulatory enforcement priorities for data & AI

In late 2023 and early 2024, federal and state regulators signaled their enforcement priorities regarding the use of data and AI. These enforcement priorities range from sweeping investigations into entire labor sectors to targeting specific uses of technology.
FEDERAL

FTC. The FTC continues bringing actions against companies over their improper use of AI, increasing the risks of LLMs and generative AI. On March 8, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) entered a stipulated order with Rite Aid prohibiting the pharmacy chain from using any machine-based systems to analyze biometric information. A month before, the FTC announced proposed rules combating the use of AI to impersonate individuals, which includes potentially imposing a rule that would declare it unlawful for an AI platform to provide goods or services that the platform knows or has reason to know is being used to harm consumers through impersonation.

SEC. In a surprising regulatory move, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) took action against two entities that made misleading disclosures regarding their use of AI. On March 18, 2024, the SEC announced a $400,000 settlement against two investment advisers for making false and misleading statements about their purported use of AI. The investors allegedly stated in its SEC filings, in press releases, and on their websites that they were harnessing AI tools in certain ways, when in fact they were not. The SEC published an AI and investment fraud alert, signaling that they will likely continue monitoring AI-related disclosures.


CALIFORNIA

Data Minimization. On April 2, 2024, the California Privacy Protection Agency (the Agency) released its first Enforcement Advisory notice, emphasizing that covered businesses must apply the principle of data minimization to every purpose for which they collect, use, retain, and share personal information. Specifically, the Agency focused on the principle of data minimization during two scenarios: (1) responding to a consumer’s request to opt-out of sale/sharing and (2) verifying a consumer’s identity. Failure to adhere to the principle of data minimization may constitute a violation of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and its regulations.

Amended CCPA Regulations. On March 29, 2024, the amended CCPA regulations will take effect and be enforceable. These regulations were originally supposed to take effect on March 29, 2023, but the California Chamber of Commerce filed suit on March 30, 2023, arguing that the amended regulations could not enter into force until one year after finalization. The court agreed, thereby effectively pushing the enforcement date back to March 29, 2024. However, a California appellate court subsequently reversed that decision, thereby making the regulations effective immediately.

The Agency and the California Attorney General have indicated that they anticipate aggressively enforcing the new regulations, and since covered entities had nearly an extra year to comply with the new regulations, California regulators may not be lenient in providing cure periods for noncompliance with the new regulations.

Streaming Services. On January 26, 2024, the California Attorney General announced investigative sweeps into “popular streaming apps and devices,” and sending letters to businesses that fail to comply with the CCPA. Specifically, the AG’s sweep focuses on whether streaming services are complying with the CCPA’s opt-out requirements for selling or sharing consumer personal information. The sweep includes analyzing whether the streaming services “do not offer an easy mechanism for consumers who want to stop the sale of their data.” For example, consumers using a SmartTV should be able to easily enable a “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” setting in the streaming service and have that choice honored across different devices.

Connected Vehicles and Related Technologies. On July 31, 2023, the Agency announced investigative sweeps into the data privacy practices of connected vehicle manufacturers and related technologies. The Agency conducted the review under the CCPA and its regulations enforceable at the time, with a focus on whether connected vehicle manufacturers and the like provided consumers with rights under the law (e.g., right to know, right to delete, and right to opt out of sale/share). However, the Agency has not indicated whether the sweep will continue into 2024 as the new regulations take effect, so connected vehicle manufacturers and producers of related technologies should remain vigilant.


COLORADO

Global Privacy Control. In the fall of 2023, the Colorado Department of Law accepted applications for universal opt-out mechanisms (UOOMs) that, under the Colorado Privacy Act (CPA), covered businesses would need to respect as a means for consumers to opt out of the sale of personal data or the sharing of personal data for targeted advertising. In December of 2023, the Colorado Attorney General announced that it selected the Global Privacy Control (GPC) as the UOOM the AG considers valid under the CPA.

Beginning on July 1, 2024, organizations subject to the CPA must ensure they are able to accept consumer opt-out requests made using the GPC, and the AG has announced that it “will prioritize for enforcement” compliance with the Department’s list of acceptable UOOMs.


CONNECTICUT

General Enforcement. On February 2, 2024, the Connecticut Attorney General released a report on the Connecticut Data Privacy Act (CTDPA), which detailed the AG’s enforcement efforts and priorities. Since the CTDPA took effect, the AG has issued cure notices to covered entities in a wide range of industries, including retail, fitness, event services, career services, parenting technologies, and home improvement.

The cure notices identified the following deficiencies:

    • Lacking or inadequate disclosures (e.g., failure to inform consumers completely or sufficiently about their rights under the law);
    • Lacking rights mechanisms (e.g., failure to provide a webpage that enables consumers to opt out of targeted advertising or sale of data);
    • Burdensome rights mechanisms (e.g., rights mechanisms that did not take into account the ways consumers normally interact with the company); and,
    • Broken / inactive rights mechanisms (e.g., non-working links or dead-end mechanisms).

Taken together, the report indicates an interest in the AG to ensure covered entities (in a wide range of industries) provide sufficient privacy disclosures and compliant rights mechanisms.


BEST PRACTICES CHECKLIST As we move through 2024, businesses should consider the following to lower their risk of enforcement actions:
  • Analyze State Privacy Thresholds. Each of the US state privacy laws feature their own thresholds of applicability that must be met before a business must comply with the law, so businesses must continually monitor whether they have satisfied any of these numerous thresholds. To help, we have compiled all of the state privacy law thresholds.
  • Create Data Maps. Because state and international privacy laws impose certain obligations on specific types of data (e.g., personal v. sensitive) and processing activities (e.g., using AI for significant decisions), businesses should create data maps to monitor and document their information practices.
  • Respect Opt-Out Signals. Where a state privacy law requires respecting opt-out preference signals, ensure that you have implemented a means for websites to recognize and respect such signals, and disclose to consumers that they have the right to use such opt-out mechanisms (e.g., Global Privacy Control).
  • Review Policies. While many of the disclosure requirements of US privacy laws and regulations overlap, there are intricate differences between them, so businesses should review external-facing policies to ensure the disclosures remain accurate and compliant.
  • Conduct DPIAs. Conduct a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) to the extent required by applicable state privacy laws or review existing DPIAs to ensure they remain compliant with applicable laws.
  • Analyze AI Tools. Understand and document how the business uses AI tools, which includes understanding the AI’s inputs and outputs, ensuring appropriate data minimization and IP safeguards are implemented, and analyzing disclosures regarding the use of the AI tools. This includes implementing an internal AI policy that covers whether and to what extent employees can use AI tools.
0

Metaverse Law to speak at OCBA Health Care Law Section Meeting

Healthcare Data, Trackers, & Artificial Intelligence: Are You Giving Away Sensitive Healthcare Information?

  Metaverse Law’s Lily Li will be speaking on this topic at this month’s OCBA Health Care Law Section Meeting. When? Thursday, March 14, 2024 12:30 PM – 1:30 PM Where? OCBA Offices 4101 Westerly Place Newport Beach, CA 92660 Click here for more information and to register for the event. *Advance registration required. No Walk-Ins.*
0
Orange County Lawyer Magazine Logo

Metaverse Law featured in OC Lawyer Magazine

The Orange County Bar Association recently released the January 2024 issue of Orange County Lawyer magazine. This month, Orange County Lawyer includes an article written by Metaverse Law’s Lily Li.

Read “AI Generated Deepfakes: Potential Liability and Remedies” below or in Orange County Lawyer magazine.

 

[Originally published as a Feature Article: AI-Generated Deepfakes: Potential Liability and Remedies, by Lily Li, in Orange County Lawyer Magazine, January 2024, Vol. 66 No.1, page 26.]

AI-Generated Deepfakes: Potential Liability and Remedies

 

by Lily Li

 

Almost ten years ago, in Netflix’s hit series House of Cards, the Underwoods’ presidential bid is almost derailed by a leaked picture of an affair, nude shower scene and all. While the picture was real, the Underwoods were able to undermine the credibility of the leaked image by claiming it was fake—going so far as to recreate the image using a hired model, to show how “easy” it was to fabricate photos.

This episode, aptly named “The Road to Power,” highlights one of the greatest risks of disinformation and fake or synthetic media. It is not through the public’s gullibility to doctored images; it is the watering down of trust in online media, leading individuals to rely solely on friends, family, and other sources of information that echo their own beliefs and values.

Fast forward a decade, and synthetic media—also known as “deepfakes” –-are now pervasive. In early 2022, for example, a fake video of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky circulated on social media, calling for his soldiers to lay down their arms and surrender to Russia.[1] At the corporate level, deepfakes have been used to mimic a CEO’s voice to fraudulently transfer $243,000.[2] Just as troubling, and even more creepy, a “sophisticated hacking team” impersonated the CEO of cryptocurrency company Binance by using “video footage of his past TV appearances and digitally alter[ing] it to make an ‘AI hologram’ of him and trick people into meetings.”[3] At home, scammers can use deepfaked voices to mimic loved ones, or AI-powered chatbots to engage in romance scams via text messages and phone calls. This is just a front to ask the victim to wire money, send gift cards, or reveal personal information to engage in identity theft. The problem has become so severe that both the FTC and the FCC have released consumer alerts in early 2023 regarding these AI-generated scams.[4]

The ease in which generative AI can create realistic videos, voice, and text will only aggravate these concerns. Deepfakes have long relied on machine learning to iterate and become more realistic with training, but in the past, this type of technology required significant computing resources and time. Now, almost every tech product is incorporating generative AI or machine learning in some form, making this accessible to every novice programmer or script kiddie.

Given these growing risks, this article will focus on the potential liability that creators, platforms, and publishers face in creating and spreading deepfakes, as well as the challenges of pursuing remedies under existing laws. In addition, this article will discuss pending rulemaking governing deepfakes and potential steps forward.

 

Privacy Liability for Deepfakes

Biometrics: If deepfakes rely on scans of faceprints, facial geometry, or voiceprints to make the false video or audio, or even to train their algorithms, then biometric privacy laws may apply. The Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) is one of the strictest data privacy laws in the country. It requires express written consent and meaningful disclosures prior to any use and disclosure of Illinois resident biometric data. The collection of biometric data is interpreted broadly to include faceprints and voiceprints. It provides a private right of action, up to $5,000 in statutory damages per violation, and does not require a showing of harm.[5] Earlier this year, in Cothron v. White Castle Systems, Inc.,[6] the Illinois Supreme Court went even further, confirming that each scan in violation of BIPA counts as an ongoing violation—adding further teeth to this law.

Revenge Porn Laws: To the extent the deepfakes include pornographic images, several states, like Virginia,[7] have explicitly included deepfakes within “revenge porn” laws, while other victims have pursued claims under existing revenge porn laws by claiming that the deepfakes amount to non-consensual pornography. The legal consequences vary by jurisdiction, ranging from misdemeanors to felonies with fines and jail time. New York and California also provide a private right of action for deepfake pornography.

General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR): The EU has a broad privacy law that governs use of personal data. Unlike U.S. state privacy laws, which generally allow free use of publicly available data (except for biometric processing), the EU requires all individuals, companies, and non-profits to have a lawful basis for processing any personal data—with limited exclusions for personal data “manifestly made public by the data subject.” Thus, indiscriminate scraping of social media data for deepfakes, especially where the users have limited the audience for their data, would likely violate the GDPR and be subject to fines and regulatory scrutiny.

 

IP, Torts, and other Remedies

Defamation: Traditional defamation claims are also applicable to deepfakes, if the plaintiff can show that the deepfake is communicated to third parties and makes false assertions that harms the plaintiff’s reputation. For public figures, plaintiffs must also show malice.

Rights of Publicity: Many states recognize a “right of publicity” to an individual’s voice or image. The damages or royalties from a right to publicity claim are proportionate to the value associated with licensing one’s image, so these types of claims are more appropriate for celebrities that ordinarily profit from licensing their image.

Copyright and Trademark: To the extent deepfakes use existing logos, photos, music, or even unique website designs to make them seem official or legitimate, this may support multiple claims of copyright and trademark infringement. Copyright holders may also send copyright takedown notices under the DMCA for infringing conduct.

Breach of Contract: If deepfakes rely on scraped content from existing sites or platforms, this may also support a breach of contract claim against the offending party (to the extent they’ve signed up and agreed to the platform’s rules). For example, in the widely publicized case, hiQ Labs, Inc. v. LinkedIn Corp., the Ninth Circuit found that hiQ breached LinkedIn’s User Agreement both through its own scraping of LinkedIn’s site and through its use of independent contractors to log into LinkedIn and do quality control of the data.[8] The Ninth Circuit noted, however, that LinkedIn was estopped from pursuing certain claims due to how much time had elapsed since its initial awareness of data scraping. Consequently, platforms that wish to rely on breach of contract claims to combat data scrapers, and potential misuse of their platforms for generative AI and deepfakes, must act swiftly and definitively. This is likely the impetus for X Corp’s (formerly Twitter) recent slew of crackdown on data scrapers, through a series of lawsuits filed in August.[9]

State Deepfake Laws: California, Texas, and Virginia have also enacted deepfake laws specific to political deepfakes, but these laws are limited in application and remedy. Texas SB 751, for instance, prohibits deepfake videos created “with intent to injure a candidate or influence the result of an election” and which are “published and distributed within thirty days of an election.” This law makes violations a Class A misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail and fines up to $4,000. More recently, Washington State passed a law requiring clear and transparent notices on any synthetic video or audio concerning candidates if it is related to an election. Senate Bill 5152 gives candidates a private right of action, including attorney’s fees for the prevailing party.

 

Limitations of Existing Remedies; Section 230 of the Communication Decency Act

There are several hurdles that would-be plaintiffs face in pursuing deepfake claims. For many torts like defamation and right of publicity, the amount of damages may be limited compared to the cost of litigation, and important First Amendment rights protect non-commercial speech that is satirical or political commentary. In addition, deepfake content can easily cross borders, so it may be difficult to find a defendant to penalize or enjoin. Consequently, instead of pursuing traditional claims, many victims rely solely on IP takedown notices, or a social media platform’s own processes to flag and remove deepfake content.

At present, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act also shields platforms from liability for the content users upload and distribute on their platforms, as platforms generally do not constitute the “speaker” or “publisher” of such content. The line between acting as a pure platform, and contributing or generating harmful content, is increasingly blurred, however. In the recent Supreme Court case, Twitter, Inc. v. Taamneh et al,[10] plaintiffs alleged that social media platforms profited from ISIS recruitment videos and allowed ISIS to take advantage of the social media platforms’ “recommendation” algorithms that match content. While the Supreme Court declined to address the scope of 230 protections for these types of “recommendation” algorithms—the Supreme court noted that Section 230 may not protect platforms that create text, audio, or video through generative AI. In oral arguments to Google v. Gonzales, a companion case to Taamneh, Justice Gorsuch strongly implied that generative AI would fall outside of Section 230’s protections, stating: “I mean, artificial intelligence generates poetry, it generates polemics today. That—that would be content that goes beyond picking, choosing, analyzing, or digesting content. And that is not protected. Let’s—let’s assume that’s right, okay?”[11]

Going forward, we anticipate that the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, and pending bills on biometric data, will likely be a more promising and lucrative way to attack platforms that explicitly use biometric data to generate or share deepfakes. In addition, as noted above, plaintiffs may have more luck pursuing claims against platforms that help create deepfake content or media using generative AI rather than solely relying on user content.

 

Do We Need Additional Laws?

As we can see from the patchwork of common law and statutory rights, the potential risks for creating and publishing deepfakes is many, but the best avenue for plaintiffs to pursue a remedy is unclear. Even some regulators are scratching their heads as to whether existing rules apply to deepfakes. For example, in July 2023, Public Citizen filed a petition with the Federal Election Commission (FEC), asking the FEC to amend its regulation on “fraudulent misrepresentation” at 11 C.F.R. § 110.16[12] to clarify that “the restrictions and penalties of the law and the Code of Regulations are applicable” should “candidates or their agents fraudulently misrepresent other candidates or political parties through deliberately false [AI]-generated content in campaign ads or other communications.”[13] In response, the FEC submitted a notice, soliciting public comment on this issue before making a decision on the merits of the petition.

The FTC has taken a firmer stance, stating that it does have authority to regulate AI generally, and deepfakes more specifically. In a March 2023 blog post titled “Chatbots, deepfakes, and voice clones: AI deception for sale,” the FTC noted that the “FTC Act’s prohibition on deceptive or unfair conduct can apply if you make, sell, or use a tool that is effectively designed to deceive—even if that’s not its intended or sole purpose.”[14]

Abroad, the European Union is taking an entirely different approach, developing a comprehensive law (the EU “AI Act”) that would govern artificial intelligence as a whole. The law, as drafted, requires all high-risk AI processing to undergo risk assessments for bias, safety, accuracy, and other risks. In addition, the AI Act would require transparency obligations for deepfakes, defined as “AI systems that generate or manipulate image, audio or video content.”[15] While the AI Act is still in draft form, it is likely to have as large and wide sweeping of an impact as the General Data Privacy Regulation, once it goes into effect.

Given the existing plethora of rights and remedies under the law, and the potential impact of the EU AI Act, this author does not believe that this is the right time to pursue a federal law specific to deepfakes—even though they present serious threats. In the current divisive political climate, it is likely that any proposed law will either get blocked, watered down, or if passed—fail to strike the right balance between free speech and misleading content. Instead, courts and regulators should strictly enforce existing laws that protect individual privacy and image rights, and the right to be free from false and deceptive practices. Attorneys should advise their tech clients on the risks of generative AI technologies and the potential gaps in Section 230 coverage. Finally, as private citizens, let’s remain diligent in what we read and share—and not be afraid to call out anyone who seeks to deceive.

 

ENDNOTES

(1) Bobby Allyn, Deepfake video of Zelenskyy could be ’tip of the iceberg’ in info war, experts warn, NPR (Mar. 16, 2022, 8:26 PM), https://www.npr.org/2022/03/16/1087062648/deepfake-video-zelenskyy-experts-war-manipulation-ukraine-russia.

(2) Catherine Stupp, Fraudsters Used AI to Mimic CEO’s Voice in Unusual Cybercrime Case, Wallstreet Journal (Aug. 30, 2019, 12:52 PM),  https://www.wsj.com/articles/fraudsters-use-ai-to-mimic-ceos-voice-in-unusual-cybercrime-case-11567157402.

(3) Luke Hurst, Binance executive says scammers created deepfake ’hologram’ of him to trick crypto developers, Euronews (Aug. 24, 2022, 2:47 PM), https://www.euronews.com/next/2022/08/24/binance-executive-says-scammers-created-deepfake-hologram-of-him-to-trick-crypto-developer.

(4) Alvaro Puig, Scammers use AI to enhance their family emergency schemes, Federal Trade Commission (Mar. 20, 2023), https://consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts/2023/03/scammers-use-ai-enhance-their-family-emergency-schemes; ’Grandparent’ Scams Get More Sophisticated, Federal Communications Commission, https://www.fcc.gov/grandparent-scams-get-more-sophisticated (last visited Nov. 29, 2023).

(5) See Rosenbach v. Six Flags Entertainment Corp., 2019 IL 123186 (Jan. 25, 2019).

(6) 2023 IL 128004 (Feb. 17, 2023).

(7) Va. Code Ann. § 18.2-386.2.

(8) No. 17-3301 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2022).

(9) Blair Robinson, X Corp Lawsuits Target Data Scraping, National Law Review (Aug. 17, 2023), https://www.natlawreview.com/article/x-corp-lawsuits-target-data-scraping.

(10) 598 U.S. 471 (May 18, 2023).

(11) Transcript of Oral Argument at 49, Google v. Gonzales, 598 U.S. 617 (2023) (No. 21-1333).

(12) Available at https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-11/section-110.16.

(13) Artificial Intelligence in Campaign Ads, 88 Fed. Reg. 55606 (proposed Aug. 16, 2023), https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/08/16/2023-17547/artificial-intelligence-in-campaign-ads.

(14) Michael Atleson, Chatbots, deepfakes, and voice clones: AI deception for sale, Federal Trade Commission (Mar. 20, 2023), https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2023/03/chatbots-deepfakes-voice-clones-ai-deception-sale.

(15) Tambiama Madiega, Artificial intelligence act, EU Legislation in Progress, European Parliament (June 2023), https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2021/698792/EPRS_BRI(2021)698792_EN.pdf.

 

Lily Li is a data privacy, AI, and cybersecurity lawyer and founder of Metaverse Law. She is a certified information privacy professional for the United States and Europe and is a GIAC Certified Forensic Analyst for advanced incident response and computer forensics.

1 … 5 6 7 8 9